Deer Farmer

Go Back   Deer Farmer > Deer Farming Forum > Cervid Industry

Cervid Industry Cervid Industry Forum - share, discuss, and debate important issues and matters within the cervid industry

LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes

Old Oct 1st 2014, 09:17 AM   #1
  Nov 2012
  Garnett, Kansas

18pxCharly Seale: Fix Deer Farm Regulation

The Charleston Gazette

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

By Charly Seale

In the last legislative session, West Virginia came very close to passing a measure that would open new paths to economic growth. Throughout the country, including in West Virginia, deer and elk are raised on private ranches for food, velvet and hunting purposes.

Members of both parties in the Legislature proposed a perfectly sensible way to regulate these farms: As farms, under the Department of Agriculture. Under current law, the Department of Natural Resources regulates cervid farms, leading to non-free-ranging animals being treated as wildlife.

Unlike deer and elk that range freely and run wild across the state, farmed cervids are contained on fenced facilities. However, natural resources administrators claim that the existence of Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD), a rare cervid disease that is not transmissible to humans, means that these farms should remain under the strict control of the Division of Natural Resources.

Presently, cervid farms are highly regulated in how they go about their businesses. But too often they face persecution from wildlife agencies that want to ban interstate transport of deer and elk or ban the opening of new farms in certain areas. In turn, the scary claims of wildlife agencies in West Virginia and other states spur fear in the hunting community. If hunters should be concerned about something, however, it isn’t deer and elk farming: It’s the practices of the wildlife agencies themselves.

The very Division of Natural Resources that bashes deer farms in West Virginia is considering a plan to import wild elk without following the same federal protocol that cervid farms do.

Before deer and elk can be sent across state lines by a farm, the facility must be CWD certified, a program administered by the USDA. This means that every eligible mortality (any animal over 12 months of age that dies) in the facility must be tested for CWD for a minimum of five years. Many ranches have been certified for over 10 years. (Ranches must also be fenced in, conduct regular inventories, individually identify animals, and test for other diseases.)

This is a strict protocol for mitigating the risk of CWD spreading. But the Virginia Department of Game and Inland Fisheries did not follow this federal protocol when they recently reintroduced elk into the state. The same is true of the Missouri Department of Conservation, which also reintroduced elk without following USDA protocol. Missouri didn’t follow established protocol, but then had the audacity to play the blame game with cervid farms.

Now, West Virginia has plans to reintroduce elk in the southern part of the state. In truth, neither the farmed nor the free-ranging animals that might be imported into West Virginia are likely to pose a threat to the native deer populations. The best evidence available indicates CWD is not particularly contagious. USDA states “the scientific knowledge we have suggests that CWD is not highly infectious.”

Further, CWD is rare. According to USDA data, roughly four in 1,000 free ranging cervids tested upon death for signs of CWD show the disease, higher than the rate of farmed cervids. And just to be safe, if CWD is found in a farmer’s herd, the herd has to be depopulated. This can ruin a farmer’s investment and reputation, and provides a strong incentive against taking steps that might risk infecting the herd.

So what is the Division of Natural Resources doing with its finger-pointing and scare campaigns? It’s simple — they’re demonstrating why they shouldn’t regulate cervid farming. Agriculture regulators simply have much more experience dealing with the issues that present themselves in farming. They know how to assess risk and govern farms.

Cervid farmers aren’t asking for a unregulated free-for-all. We’re just asking to be treated like other agriculture industries.

Charly Seale is president of the North American Elk Breeders Association.

Travis is offline  
Old Oct 17th 2021, 04:30 AM   #2
  Sep 2021
  New South Wales
Deer farm regulation so necessary

Definitely it's really important to make the deer farm regulation more proper. I heard from my friend last week there were a deer escaped from the someone's farm and run into the roadway where my friend got a car crash and his windscreen is broken.
MikeLee is offline  

  Deer Farmer > Deer Farming Forum > Cervid Industry

charly, deer, farm, fix, regulation, seale

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Similar Discussions
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Elk and deer farm Tabeast Deer Breeding 7 Mar 20th 2015 08:41 AM
Laurie Seale: Wait for live CWD test before adding elk Travis Cervid Industry 0 Jan 25th 2015 12:20 PM
Another Deer Poached At A Minnesota Deer Farm vikingwhitetails Cervid Industry 1 Mar 22nd 2013 01:15 PM
Charly Seale Appearing On Fox And Friends vikingwhitetails Cervid Industry 4 Feb 21st 2012 03:30 PM
Great Job Charlie Seale ToddM Cervid Community 13 Jan 30th 2012 06:28 PM

Facebook Twitter Google+ RSS Feed