This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Bad luck, and nervous about buying more deer!

Joined Dec 2009
44 Posts | 0+
Henryetta,OK
This is the first time I have posted on this site since I lost most of my deer. I am thinking about getting more deer, but the past still haunts me as I truly never found out what killed my deer. I was hoping that maybe someone else had had a similar incident in the last 2 years and maybe they could shed light on the subject for me. Here is my story, some of you will remember it.



I started raising deer in 2002 with the purchase of 2 does and a buck. I live in Oklahoma and bought the deer just an hour away. Things were good for a year, so I went to Missouri and bought 2 bred does and a well bred buck fawn. Both does had triplets and all is still good. It was 2005 January and I had been raising deer 3 years and not lost a single deer, I know extremely rare!



My herd was of average genes and not monitored. I decided I did not want to start the headache of monitoring and be behind on my date, so I decided to sell all my deer and start over. This would be a chance to buy back only 200 inch blood deer and buy 6 plus years CWD status and TB and Bruc accredited. I went to Minnesota. I bought 5 bred does and one doe fawn. The does were all 200 plus over 3 generations and bred to 240 plus bucks. Do to snow, we could not pick them up until March 26th. The deer were darted the day before and put in a barn. 2 of the does were from one farm the other 4 were from another 5 miles away. We loaded the deer and drove 11 hours home and unloaded them. These deer were from big pens and pretty wild, could not get within 50 yards very easily. They acted fine about a week, then I noticed one lay down and abort her fawns. Theses does varied from extremely wild to very tame. After about two weeks, mid April, I found the 2 wildest deer dead laying by the fence, I assumed they crashed the fence and killed themselves in the night. About 2 days later I found another dead, by the 3rd week in April 3 were dead with the doe fawn in perfect health and the most gentle 2 does, very poor, and overly tame, then she started standing around with her tongue hung out alot. I sprayed the pen, and began feeding Ivomec, the two does did last a few weeks and seemed to get better, but both of them died by May 1st. The doe fawn is still alive and never lost weight or got sick. I thought EHD, but is that too early? Maybe the late move? Stress? change of feed? Either way it wiped me out! To one deer. Everyone on this forum thought it was the combination of the deer being darted late, the long drive home and then mixing these deer together that were strangers. Tim C thought maybe the fawns were killed with the darting and thats why the does died. It all made sense to me, since the doe fawn survived.



Well that was May 2005, I had one doe fawn. She made it just fine, never got sick. I spoke with the guy in Minnesota and he felt bad, so he offered me a good deal on 3 does to try again, this time I picked them up February 26th, 1 full month earlier. All 3 were adult does and bred. The deer did well for over a month, I began to feel Tim was right about darting them too late, then it happened, about the first week in April another doe went down, I was out of town and when I got back the second doe was showing signs. They would stand around in a daze with their tongue out and within a few days they would die. I was home and with the second doe when she died, as was my vet. He cut her open and sent her organs to OSU. Her liver looked awful, full of lesions. OSU said she died from liver failure from a PYRROLIZIDINE ALKALOID, most likely poisoning, and most likely from bad weeds in my pen. I moved the remaining doe to a pen with only bermuda grass( and the survivor fawn). They were doing fine and it was now mid may. I came home to find two dogs in my pen killing the grown doe, I shot both of them and she died a few hours later. I sold the fawn and quit deer.



I really enjoyed the deer and miss them, but still have the fear factor. The only thing I could think of it that there are weeds growing in my pens that must emerge in late March or early April, and since they are the first green things out, the deer from the north ate them and the deer from the south were smart enough not to or were resistant to them.



I never dreamed that weeds would kill deer. I left the pens with weeds and brush because I thought it would be more natural for the deer. It is not trees, all the trees are oak, elm, cedar or hackberry, no wild cherry.



If I do decide to buy more deer, I plan to kill all the weeds and under brush with spray before getting any deer. Is it possible that some deer are immuned to some weed poisons and some deer are not? or do you think that knowing which weeds to eat is a learned habit? Why did the fawn survive and all the does died? Was the fawn more resiliant or smarter? I know that EHD affects North and South deer differently, maybe there is a lot more differences in the North and South deer than people know.
 
Hey brandon i know your feelings,i have kept up with your poistings since it all started.All i know is with deer you just gotta keep goin It do get better, mine reach through fence keep the wild cherry back. not bothered them but it not dead.i think mine immune to that.lost my share,had 15 last yr sold and lost down to couple does and buck. last 4 yrs been heck learning thing.i was counting on AI fawns,plenty deer right here Give me holler David 918-367-2072 if busy try try again wife stays on computer!!:D i had my share bad luck it get better!! might as well if you got pens! need tame to start.BOL
 
You don't think that it might have something to do with the climate change do you? I mean your taking deer that are used to very cold winters and mild summers into a much warmer climate where it gets very hot, right around april-may. If I was you I would forget the northern deer and buy from stock in the southern states, and A.I. the northern in if you wanted that. They also might not know the weeds here in the south as these varieties might not grow in minnesota. The fawn being young might have been able to adapt better as young-uns are known to survive situations where the adults don't.
 
It was not the climate change, there are tons of deer in Oklahoma that came from Wisconsin, Illinois and Minnesota.Most of the big deer in Oklahoma are not southern blood, they are of northern bloodlines!
 
Brandon, sorry about your troubles. You might go to the old forums and do a search on weeds, seems like they showed pics of some of the bad ones.Where in Ok are you located. We are in the NE part give us a call if needed
 
Brandon Wheeler said:
It was not the climate change, there are tons of deer in Oklahoma that came from Wisconsin, Illinois and Minnesota.Most of the big deer in Oklahoma are not southern blood, they are of northern bloodlines!



understood, but different animals handle things differently, the first time around the combination of being pregnant, being darted, and new pen mates, could be the answer, there could also be the possiblity of weeds, something in the water that there not used to, change of diet, different climate, etc. just to many factors the first time around. the second time around with the does having the same syptoms I would say something is in the pen, be it the water, grass, feed, something similiar, again it might be the climate change as the second set of does did the same thing, but most likely something they ate, if it's weeds then the climate difference would be the answer being in a climate where x weed grows and in there home climate it doesn't, at least that's my 2 cents.
 
I know I had weeds in the pen, I raise cows too and the cows are smart enough to not eat the bad weeds. I know I had Jimson weeds, Poke, Milkweed, lots of ragweeds, eupitoria, mares tail, iron weeds, lambs quarters, blackberry, green briars, buck brush and a weed that resembles photos of Hounds Tongue. I knew I had weeds, I just never heard any issues with weeds until after my problem. Also the pens the deer came from up north were mostly dirt with short grass, no weeds at all! No trees!



The guy I bought them from said he has a billionaire in Missouri that buys 10 shooters a year from him, he must sell him 10 - 4 year old that are 180 plus inches. He raises about 20 bucks a year to meet this guys demands. They take them to a 6,000 acre high fence and turn them loose in Missouri. He told me that if the bucks are not shot in 3 weeks, most of them will die. He does not know why, maybe its weeds, but I have been told by Sam James that there is a disease in Missouri called Valeria that is carried by ticks and it will wipe out northern deer fast.





James,

I am just north of Tim C in Henryetta area.
 
:eek:I found out this yr That a dog could get tick fever!! he bout died. ticks, BAD!! I found them crumbles cleans em out for couple yrs. If it in Mo it Here!! Good info. Tween the Midge and Ticks, horsefly.deer fly!! all them other flying critters not sure what they are but they get up ther nose. Millions of them. Bad ass Warble Fly. gets under skin. bugs bad in okla.and the poison weeds! EHD<BT<Dang.Im dreamin up dip tank,either swim or drown !:D probably saves on spraying.
 
I think sometimes we overlook plain ole stress.:eek: from the move, seperation, introduced to some more ***** does.:eek:capture stress, when the stress switch is activated.some never recover, some my thinking only Dc