Oklahoma man sentenced for poaching breeder buck

Deer Farmer Forum

Help Support Deer Farmer Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Apr 13, 2009
Messages
19
Oklahoma man sentenced for poaching breeder buck









OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) — A Newalla man will spend 10 days in jail and agreed to never hunt again as part of his sentence for poaching a tame white-tailed deer that was used for breeding.





Twenty-five-year-old Justin Ray McDaniel was sentenced Wednesday for shooting the buck “Pretty Boy” with a bow and arrow in 2008. He pleaded guilty in November to charges of grand larceny of exotic livestock and making a false statement at a hunter check station.



McDaniel said he shot the buck because he wanted to “sound like a cool guy.”



McDaniel must also pay $33,000 restitution to the owner and the breeder of the deer.



A prosecutor says the owner and breeder lost from $493,000 to $1.1 million in potential breeding income because of the deer’s death.
 
I know it probably doesn't sound like enough money. But with any kind of live stock they could drop dead the next day. I'm sure thats why he didn't have to pay "potential income"
 
My guess would be that they gave him $33,000 to replace the buck. I did not see the buck or know anything about the deer, but my guess is they can find a better buck than him for half that.



It was a bad deal, but realistically, how do you justify asking for future sales, when they have not happened and also the amount given is enough to replace him. I think the money is fair.......but I think the guy should have got more jail time, at least 2 year!
 
The problem with jail time is he would not be able to pay the fine. He also got a lifetime ban on hunting. With reciprocal laws around the country he will never be able to hunt. He also got 10 years probation and thats a long time. I think it was plenty of punishment and I would rather have him out of jail paying the owner than be in jail costing taxpayers $50,000.00 a year. He also had a large fine levied on him. If he don't pay the fine and the restitution he will have to serve the 10 years. I think it is a very good example to show what the consequenses are in Oklahoma for rustling a deer. In the old days we wuda hung'im.
 

Recent Discussions

Back
Top