Your thoughts on this bucks chances

what world record are we talking about? Goliath at 329 6/8 or Rolex at 377 never did here his official score but i see they keep advertising him as worlds largest buck.

My thinking is Goliath was 410" and some change, and Highroller was 417". Rolex was at 377", and Jeckle 355". Again, Thats what I believe. And MOST of the time it doesent count.

Let me finish to say, this is going to be a BIG argument when he is scored. There is going to be manure threw everywhere, so get ready. There is so much hype already built up, not only in the deer breeding world but in the hunting mags. Not picking sides at all, and sorry Roger for saying this, but lets not forget about some of these other "hidden" deer that might give the "world record" another run.

I think without a doubt sudden Impact is on his way to becoming the next World Record....but i must say and truly believe he will be replacing that record which is currently held by Goliath.......Goliath was a Buck that was way before the times!! He never got the recognition he deserved because of the whole situation surrounding him.....I wish the Flees family the best and may their experience be much better than the Millers had when they held the Title. Hopefully, things will go smoothly for them.

Reed68 said:

but lets not forget about some of these other "hidden" deer that might give the "world record" another run.

Click to expand...

Sudden Impact is not alone. He's still gotta beat some 4, 5, and 6 year olds that are making a run as well...

No Roger, I didn't mean to start any crap. I think its fun. I'll fix it. Then back you if it starts again.

Roger, Interesting tread you started here. This could be fun to see how others evaluate Sudden Impact's future. I voted that he will break the record, but will not hit 500". I think he is a monster and used him last year in 9 does. There is another deer brewing right now... He is a 2 year old... He is absolutely huge with a great pedigree. Probably 75 or more points! I don't want to steal Sudden Impacts thunder here so that's all I will say for now. Go Sudden Impact!

Roger, I like the post. I too was wondering if Sudden Impact will top the rest of the group. There are many great challengers to the title held by Goliath. The Millers are great people and very good friends of mine. I'm sure they will be the first to call and hand the title over to whomever has EARNED IT. It funny for us because we have a Goliath doe, 2 Sudden Impact buck fawns, 2 Rolex does and I'm sure many others that someday will be in the running for the title. I just hope to have one or two that you guys are talking(good) about someday. Isn't that what we are all doing this for. Best of luck to all who have the GREAT BUCKS.......

There's nothing for you to feel bad about Roger... I'll leave it at that.

Great post Roger. I think there are a lot of people with opinions on this subject that wanted someone else to start the outlet...As far as the world record debate goes, it'll be debated til the end of time probably. There's no way to justify trying to judge these deer based on our opinion of the score. Between highroller and goliath I would have to say I prefer highroller. Is there another deer out there that has produced so many huge sons that produce huge sons? I think we'll see several deer pass these two legends in the near future but the question is will they become legends? Will they compare to either one of these deer let alone Max or maxbo? Will Rolex be to highroller like maxbo is to max? Pass him up and make every doe with a uterus a "proven" doe? Dont know if sudden impact will make 500 or not, but if he or any other deer comes even close I believe that they should be panel scored at nadefa if they want to truly hold any sort of record, and my personal opinion is a gross B&C score, thats the scale we all charge shooters off of so that should be what we score breeders off of. I dont expect anyone to agree with me, just throwing my thoughts in the ring.



Of the deer "known" he probably has the best chance with his young age to break 500" but I dont think he'll do it this year.

B.S. RWalkjr, You cant do that. Thats against the law!!!!!!!!!

Come on, Bring it??????????



Hey Micheal, I've got some sale catelogs with Rolex, Goliath, and Suddan Impact in them. Thats about as far as I can go. LOL

How about "Grand Canyon" from Blossers????????? Anybody seen him?

Reed, my problem is keeping them alive. I lost four buck fawns last week. One to naval infection, one to the fence, one to heat and one to a sorry B-otch of a doe that stomped him. I'm glad last week is over.

I heard grand canyon is huge. Maxbo xl is also a stud!!!! Sudden impact had better get growing. He has alot of catching up to do

Thanks Roger and Russell ...

Great thread and great feature...I love it.

Hey Reed High Roller was 418 sci and Goliath was 410 BC. Then Goliath was rescored with a panel of SCI scorers and had a world record score of 429 6/8 SCI. He was the only buck to be officialy scored by a panel of sci scorers. So therefore he is the record holder as of now and the one to beat no Questions asked. Can't wait to see how many other bucks are going to give it a run this year or next year. Here is one i have in mind (Timberjack).

Virgil, I never really followed up on the SCI score of Goliath, so thats why it is stuck in my head like that.(I told you I was wrong). Its going to take a "panel" of scorers to score these deer because of all the judgment calls. It's going to be a mess. Glad I just have 140" deer, its pretty easy to score 6 points. By the way, I'm still waiting on a pic of LowRider?????



And-----Who is "Timberjack", I havn't heard of him this year, or his yearlings?

I think all deer should be scored on a panel that have a chance to be the highest scoring typicals or non-typicals and any time anyone wants to say "World Record" anything, they should have the panel to back them. What we do now is like saying that I ran a 9.0 100 meter dash and no one was there to time me, but I broke the record? Come on guys, just bring those supposed records out and have them all scored together to see which bucks are the real records. I think everybody should be on the same playing field and it will show the true records. Just my thoughts...