Great stories guys! I guess I'll play.....
Two years ago very late in the deer season about mid February, I was sitting in my house one morning watching TV. I looked out the window and noticed a big doe and a fawn were down at the feeder. I still needed to take out a few doe for the year, so I figured I would do a little stalk hunting to start my day. So i snuck around the side of my house and closed a little ground on them using a big Oak tree to block their view. I finally got to within about 200 yrds and laid the rifle against a tree limb for a rest. I put the cross hairs on her and squeezed the trigger. BOOOM! I knew I had made a good shot as I watched her hunch up and run into the woods with the fawn trailing behind. I slowly made my way down there and found good blood and tracked her into the woods a little ways and sure enough their she was! As I was walking up to her I remember thinking "wow, that's a big bodied doe!" and as I got even closer I noticed she had a prior leg injury very similar to a big 3 yr old buck I had released to be a breeder on property, and that's when I looked up and realized this big doe was actually that big 3 yr old and had dropped his antlers early!
I was sick to my stomach, as I had nursed this buck's leg several times and he was doing great. He was a 160" 2 year old and probably about the same at 3 after his leg injury. I couldn't believe I had shot one my best young bucks WITHOUT ANTLERS
i searched high and low and only found one of his drops, so I couldn't even mount him......
So to recap what we've learned on this thread so far:
1) When trying to kill a deer with a knife, going for the throat is more effective than the ribs
2) Never turn your back on a buck, even if he's in another pen
3) Don't underestimate a buck fawn, they can be just a crazy as older deer
4) Always, take a follow up shot on head shot deer, just in case
which leads us to our next point...
5) Make sure a deer is dead before you put a tag on it
6) Red Duct tape is clearly less effective than silver
7) When riding a Red Deer always lean into the turns, and for God's sake don't spur him!
8) Late in the season, Bucks that drop their antlers will use fawns to further convince you they're a doe
I feel like we're learning a lot from this thread