About 2% of our bucks have lost their antlers.
I have found out cold weather only plays a small part of when a buck looses it’s antlers. Feed and stress plays the biggest part especially in captive deer. If it is sick, injured or moved the buck is stressed. I have found threw experience if I move Bamby from his one acre pen where he is familiar with his surroundings food, water, hay and the routine of daily life going on outside of his pen. And move him into a large hunting area in December with ample feed. Bamby will loose his antlers with in four weeks. If I move him the first of January he will shed in two weeks or less. Bucks moved in late season find a sunny southern slope and seem to loose their desire to eat as compared to when they were in their pens. I figured this out after years of experience and calling the owners of Bamby and they all said the same thing. Bamby always lost his antlers in Feb, March or even April.
If we move a shooter into a hunting area in early fall they seem to keep their antlers longer as I feel they have become familiar to their surroundings.
If any one isn’t bored by now and wants to know why wild deer usually loose their antlers early when there is a banner year for acorns. I will also tell you what 35 years as a logger and avid hunter has thought me.
Cold weather has every thing to do with it and then again nothing