As I have said all along, if it works for you then don't change a thing. We all know how difficult it can be to find our niche.
I am not looking for a fight either, but was singled out by the red cap milk crew because I suggested that the milk may be the culprit for scours, as it was in my case. This then led to a deep discussion on nutritional values and the possibilities of malnourishment.
I really don't care if a person feeds their deer dog or cat food as long as it works for them. If it works, then that's all that matters. I do think it is being a little irrational on our parts to not look at all the equations and weight them out accordingly when someone is asking for help.
When I have time, I will continue to offer my observations and suggestions when someone is asking for help, regardless of who's feelings or pride it affects. I have never been a politically correct kind of guy and basically call it as I see it. I hope the folks on here can respect that.
The funniest part about this industry today is, it reminds me a lot of my sisters beauty salon. As soon as one lady gets or tries something new, all the other women soon do the same, just so they can say they have one or are doing it too, regardless of what the widget is.
Last year the red cap milk was starting to be talked about as the new and exciting solution for feeding fawns. The year before it was Fox Valley, the previous year before it was Zoologic and so on and so on... Unfortunately in the red cap situation, last year a fellow having fawns at around the 10-11 week old range, were breaking legs left and right. We are not talking one or two broken legs, we are talking three and four legs on one fawn broken from just running. Needless to say, after four or five fawns broke their legs, he sent one of them off for a necropsy and found out it was malnourished.
This could have been due to a couple reasons including the feed he fed his doe with and from the milk he used to bottle feed with. As I understand it, the milk was the more probable culprit in this situation. Is this something that could happen in every case? We don't know and it may be a bit early and unfair to suggest red cap milk as the new wonder solution for feeding fawns.
Please understand what it is your are feeding your animals with, and the consequence, before jumping on the bandwagon and trying the newest fads. Consult with your Vet and ask his professional opinion before using. Keep in mind, my Vet did tell me to use the whole milk a few feedings "if" it was the only thing I had available at the time. Then as soon as I could, get something with higher fat, protein and mineral levels and slowly transition the fawn to the replacer. I tried the milk for 2 weeks and did not like to results. It may have been that I didn't feed it in the larger quantities that seems to go hand and hand with the suggestions from the folks that are using it and like it.
I am not trying to hurt peoples reputation or feelings, but rather trying to educate everyone as to the experiences I had, and others have had using a product. Many of the people that visit this forum do not have access to Vets that work with deer, so they rely on the information that gets posted here. I felt really bad about all the fawns that had broke their legs and had to be put down. I also felt even worse for the fellow that had a great crop of A/I babies and lost most of them to malnourishment.
I agree, red cap is a much cleaner and easier product to use, but at what price to the fawn, is all I am insinuating. I also agree, and so does our Vet, that red cap will indeed save a fawns life - if it's the only thing you have available at the time and fed short term....
Good luck to everyone, and I hope you find what works best for you and primarily your animals....
.