Very odd case you have there. I know our PA game commission has proven through multiple tagging and hunter harvest studies, that some of our PA 1 1/2 old bucks will very rarely grow little to no antlers at all. I read of a guy just this year who shot a tagged deer. It was a buck with no sign of ever having any antlers on his pedicals so he assumed it was a buck fawn. So he called to report his tagged kill and collect his 100 dollar reward. The game commission called him back days later and said it was 1 1/2 year old ( they tagged it as a fawn the spring before). The man reported the bucks *** organs were normal and intact, and he also made it clear it was not a buck that shed antlers, it just never had them. I seen the pics. It was just an odd case like your buck I guess. So I guess we'll al continue to be surprised by what can happen with deer, we'll never figure them out, lol.
Thanks for you update Kevin. I hope he grows some antlers for you this summer so he can at least be a little profitable for you. Let us know how he does this summer.