,every year someone starts the topic of antler shedding in December, I am always caught off guard by this subject coming up in december because in four antler shedding seasons my earliest buck to shed was on Feburary 12, that was last year, and i had nine bucks. Most of my bucks will hold on way into march, its quite amazing how some shed earlier than others. I did have a buck that lost an antler in october once while rubbing a tree, he must have wedged it in there good, but the base of the antler looked like a normal shed and he had a normal rack the next fall so no damage to pedicle, he held his other side until april. I really dont think a buck shedding early is anything to be concerned about as long as he is being his normal self, i think they just shed different times, they are indiduals, no two deer are the same.