PayDay! Win a Straw!

Bell

Joined Apr 2014

1,245 Posts | 0+

Greensburg, IN

• Sep 9, 2014

• #41

I am surprised you all were able to come to a consensus about what was the main beam after the t-3's without stripping all the velvet out there and following the veins. It is hard for me to tell just looking at the pictures and video. I look forward to seeing his horns. I edited my guess after trying to decide about it.

 

Antlershed

Joined Apr 2009

1,562 Posts | 0+

cental Pennsylvania

• Sep 9, 2014

• #42

439 3/8", total

279 1/8, frame

28 6/8" inside

47 7/8" outside,

I hope I didn't guess same as someone else, lol, but if I did it's cause I didn't take the time to go through and check everyone else's guesses.

Thanks for the game, there haven't been many this year. What a fine specimen payday is! Congrats Sam.

 

B

Brent Thomure

Joined Sep 2012

185 Posts | 0+

Hannibal, MO

• Sep 9, 2014

• #43

I have looked at the pics. I have looked at the videos.


Then I looked again and again.


After all the looking I come up with BIG really BIG.


I am thinking that should cover it. Will I get my straw in time to use it this year?


Brent

 

SJames

Joined Apr 2009

1,130 Posts | 0+

Columbia, MO

Discussion Starter
• Sep 9, 2014

• #44

Nice try Brent....Big is correct but not the RIGHT answer...lol


Johnathan, the left was an easy 6X6 skipping the one little cheater upright tine. The right was the tough one but there is a large vein line running to the beam that makes it a 6X6. A couple guys thought it went down but then it looked ridiculous!


 


One other note on this deer. I have sawed hundreds of bucks and never had such a hard time sawing through his antlers. Had another buck down and zipped right through his. PayDay was like sawing through a rock. No wonder he has never broken a point in his entire life. There is nothing porous even in the drop tines. And dense and heavy... wow! The drops last year weighed 10 lbs each. They are heavier this year.  He carries them like they are nothing. They must be perfectly balanced.


 


Thanks everyone for playing...Off to the capital tomorrow...Yikes!

 

SJames

Joined Apr 2009

1,130 Posts | 0+

Columbia, MO

Discussion Starter
• Sep 9, 2014

• #45

One other question for Johnathan from another post (you got me thinking), On his right he has an 12+ inch g1, an 18+ inch g2 and 16+ inch g3..and on....(no more hints). He also has a couple drops with one being over 10 inches. Are there any other bucks you know of with this tine length with drops?


 

 

W

walnutridgewhitetails

Joined Jun 2012

20 Posts | 0+

Narvon PA

• Sep 9, 2014

• #46

394 gross

269 mainframe

29 IS

43 OS

Thanks Lloyd

 

B

Brent Thomure

Joined Sep 2012

185 Posts | 0+

Hannibal, MO

• Sep 9, 2014

• #47

Can't blame a man for trying Sam.


I will be a little more specific this time.


 


Gross - 468"


Main frame - 289"


Inside spread - 29"


Out side spread - 47"


 


               Total - 833" of pure awesome = BIG really BIG


 


Thanks for this opportunity Brent

 

Padencreek

Joined May 2011

296 Posts | 0+

Linesville, PA

• Sep 10, 2014

• #48

I said it the first time you posted Payday and I'll say it again, he's my favorite deer this year for sure. Any pics of sons yet? 489 289 29.5 47= 854.5. Thanks!

 

C

Coyote Flatt's

Joined Jul 2013

20 Posts | 0+

Plankinton SD

• Sep 10, 2014

• #49

Gross 509

Main frame 318

Inside 32

Outside 56

Thanks, he is a awesome deer!!

 

P

ptj

Joined Sep 2014

1 Posts | 0+

Rome OH

• Sep 11, 2014

• #50

458 gross 282 main 31 inside 47 outside 824 total great buck Sam thanks

Ptj

 

Freedom Whitetails

Joined Feb 2011

912 Posts | 0+

Blair County, PA

• Sep 11, 2014

• #51

446-242-29.25-45

Great contest with more of a twist than just sci score. I like it, thanks sam

 

H

huggs1

Joined Nov 2013

4 Posts | 0+

Hot Springs AR

• Sep 15, 2014

• #52

417 6/8
272 4/8
29 2/8
43 1/8
Thanks , fine buck.

 

K

kings whitetails

Joined Jul 2011

97 Posts | 0+

Spring Glen, PA

• Sep 15, 2014

• #53

18px440 / 262 / 26 / 48


Great looking buck!!

 

M

Morton Whitetails

Joined Oct 2010

189 Posts | 0+

Pickerington, Ohio

• Sep 15, 2014

• #54

Total-416.5"


Main- 257.5"


IS- 31.5


OS-43


 


Total- 748.5"


 


Thanks Sam!

 

H

Hilltop Acres

Joined Jun 2013

27 Posts | 0+

Pennsylvania

• Sep 15, 2014

• #55

Awesome deer

Tot. 437 1/2

Main. 281 3/4

IS. 29 1/4

OS. 45 1/2


Thanks

 

B

black bayou whitetails

Joined Mar 2013

90 Posts | 0+

Louisiana

• Sep 15, 2014

• #56

great deer  thanks for the contest     42 os   28 is  291 mf     398 total

 

P

Pine Grove Whitetails

Joined Aug 2010

63 Posts | 0+

Plain City Ohio USA

• Sep 15, 2014

• #57

My guess is


 


Gross  491


Main Frame   272


Inside Spread   29.5


Outside Spread   47.5


 


24pxBIG DEER SAM!!! 


 


 


Thanks


Shawn Miller


Pine Grove Whitetails LLC

 

W

WhiteGold Whitetails

Joined Nov 2013

19 Posts | 0+

Minnesota

• Sep 16, 2014

• #58

487 3/8" gross


301 7/8" MF


27 1/8" IS


48 3/8" OS

 

M

mjwoodard

Joined Jul 2010

20 Posts | 0+

houston mn us

• Sep 16, 2014

• #59

437 gross


260 main


27 IS


44 OS


 


Thanks Sam

 

D

deerlover1

Joined Aug 2010

39 Posts | 0+

Newton Falls, Ohio, United States

• Sep 17, 2014

• #60

464 gross 307. mf. 27. is 50. os Thanks Sam !